from Channel News Asia / May 21, 2014 / A Japanese court ruled Wednesday against the restarting of two reactors at a nuclear power plant, acknowledging residents’ safety fears and dealing a blow to the government’s plan to revive nuclear power.

It was the first court ruling in Japan against the restarting of reactors since a massive earthquake and tsunami sparked meltdowns at the Fukushima nuclear plant in March 2011.

This picture taken on April 12, 2012 sho

Oi Nuclear Power Plant, Fukui Prefecture.

At present, all of Japan’s nearly 50 nuclear reactors are offline due to shutdowns or safety checks.

The regional court at Fukui in western Japan said the two reactors at the Oi plant operated by Kansai Electric Power Co. should not be restarted after safety checks because they pose “specific risks” to residents in the event of a major earthquake.

The court was responding to a lawsuit filed by a group of 189 people demanding an injunction against the restarting of the reactors. It acknowledged claims by 166 of them who live within 250 kilometres (156 miles) of the plant.

The power utility said it would appeal the ruling.

In the face of widespread public unease about nuclear power, the Nuclear Regulation Authority in July last year introduced new safety standards. These oblige plant operators to put in place specific countermeasures against serious accidents like meltdowns or tsunamis.

The government of Prime Minister Shinzo Abe said there was “no change at all” in its plan to restart nuclear reactors if they are confirmed safe.

“We will restart reactors if their safety is determined objectively in a strict sense,” said Chief Cabinet Secretary Yoshihide Suga.

Japan shut down all its nuclear reactors after Fukushima. The two reactors at Fukui resumed operations in August 2012, the first and only ones to do so.

In September last year they were stopped for regular safety checks.

SOURCE: Channel News Asia

Did you like this? Share it:
By Broc West| 5 Comments | Featured, News


  1. Reaction from The Japan News
    “Court ruling on Oi nuclear plant restart based on irrational thinking”

    The Fukui court has ignored the new safety standards that came into force for nuclear reactors in July 2013, and exhibited scant scientific knowledge.
    On May 9, the Osaka High Court upheld a lower court ruling when it turned down a similar lawsuit filed by a separate group of residents aiming to block the planned reactivation of the two Oi reactors.
    The Fukui court’s ruling obviously runs counter to the main thrust of the precedent established by the Supreme Court. Kansai Electric plans to appeal the latest ruling. We hope a higher court will hand down a more sensible decision.

    The phenomenon of attacking with lawsuits is old enough that it has a name; “barratry”.

  2. Wow. Well, that was clearly an implied threat, so it should probably should be removed, even if it does illustrate the lack of counter-arguments from the poster.

    • Agreed. Personal attacks and threats are not acceptable on this blog. Please report any such threats directly and they will be removed.

  3. “The government of Prime Minister Shinzo Abe said there was “no change at all” in its plan to restart nuclear reactors . . . ” because they’re FASCISTS.

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *